Business Directory

subnav icon More

Note: The directory is limited to businesses that are owned and operated within the Township of Lake of Bays and is not a comprehensive listing of all businesses that serve the area. Businesses in neighbouring Municipalities located near the Township boundary are included. The business directory is intended to serve as a resource for residents, businesses and visitors. The Township of Lake of Bays does not guarantee the accuracy of any listing or external website.

Would you like to be added to the Business Directory? Contact the Economic Development Coordinator or register to manage your own listing.

Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria

Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria logo
6 Bay St
Baysville, Ontario
P0B 1A0

Founded in 2010 by owner/operator Michelle MacIsaac, the Humble Pie is a popular, friendly home-style bakery located at 6 Bay Street, in beautiful downtown Baysville. With the assistance of lead baker, Jennifer Wood, they offer a selection of hearty fruit pies, pastries, butter milk scones, savoury meat pies, frozen entrées, quiche, breads, and their golden-delicious culinary delights - the infamous Humble Pie Butter Tarts! Every Saturday Jennifer whips up something special for dessert, to be pre ordered for your enjoyment. 

The Humble Pie also offers a variety of fresh and delicious Italian inspired pizzas with gluten and dairy free options available.  You can choose from their unique menu, build your own from a wide selection of fresh ingredients, or grab from a variety of ready-to-go frozen pizzas.

This busy little bakery recommends placing orders in advance to make sure you get your favourites. For updates on specials and hours of operation you can follow them on Instagram @humblepiemuskoka, on Facebook at or call 705-224-8278.



Michelle MacIsaac 705-224-8278


Contact Us